NFL · Week 11
Dolphins at Bills: the pick is Under 46.5
Miami's offense averaged under 16 points a game through Week 9 and has since lost its starting quarterback to injured reserve. Buffalo, favored by 16.5, has no reason to run up the score, and the look-ahead total is 46.5.
The setup
Buffalo hosts Miami on Sunday, Nov 22, at 1:00 PM ET (19:00 CET) at Highmark Stadium. Through nine weeks the Bills were 7–1 and the Dolphins were 1–7. Week 10 is not counted here: this pick was posted before those games were played.
The look-ahead market made Buffalo a 16.5-point favorite with a total of 46.5. The same game had been listed earlier at Bills −11.5 and 47.5. The spread moved five points; the total moved one.
Why the under
Start with Miami's offense. The Dolphins scored 126 points in their first eight games, 15.8 a game, and were held to 13 or fewer five times. That was with Malik Willis at quarterback. Willis is now on injured reserve, and Kyle McCord was the only quarterback on the active roster as of Nov 14. Running back De'Von Achane is out for the season.
Then the favorite's side of the math. A team laying 16.5 does not need a high-scoring game to win, and a big lead tends to shorten a game: more runs, fewer stoppages. Buffalo's two results before this pick were 36–10 over Baltimore and 23–6 at Minnesota, games that ended with 46 and 29 total points.
Read together, a 16.5-point spread and a 46.5 total imply a score near Buffalo 31, Miami 15. We think Miami's half of that is the generous part.
What beats it
Buffalo averaged 32 points through Week 9 and can get most of the way to the number alone. One defensive score or a late Miami touchdown is enough to push it over.
The Bills' season has also been high-scoring more often than not. Five of their first six games produced 55 points or more, and they allowed 29 or more in five of their first eight. If that defense shows up instead of the one from Weeks 8 and 9, a backup quarterback can still get Miami to 17.
The number
Under 46.5 is the pick, and we would still play it down to 45.5. At 45 or lower the edge is gone and the pick is a pass.
How we grade it
Graded on the combined final score, overtime included, against 45.5, the worst number we said we would play. A total of 45 or fewer is a win; 46 or more is a loss.
Sources
Facts were checked on Nov 15, 2026. The pick itself is our opinion.